|
A blueprint for dismantling
Medicare?
Gil McGowan, AFL Staff
The Alberta government has formally endorsed a plan for
Medicare reform that will fundamentally alter the way health services are paid
for and delivered in the province.
In late January, provincial health Minister Gary Mar
announced plans to implement all 43 recommendations put forward by the
Premier’s Advisory Council on Health, better know as the "Mazankowski
Commission."
On one level the report, authored by Mulroney-era cabinet
minister Don Mazankowski, says many things that supporters of public health can
agree with.
For example, the Council calls on the Alberta government to
explore options to the current fee-for-service model for paying physicians. It
also says we should pay more attention to preventing disease and promoting
healthy lifestyles. And it says we should invest more in health education and
research.
Many observers have pointed to these recommendations as proof
that the Mazankowski report is not really that surprising or dangerous. But the
truth is that all of report’s talk about "healthy communities and healthy
lifestyles" is just a sugar coating that has been applied to sweeten a
bitter pill.
Like other Conservative governments, the Klein government in
Alberta realizes that Medicare is extremely popular with the public – so they
have avoided any direct references to eliminating or replacing the system.
Instead, the Mazankowski report opts for vague language that seems deliberately
designed to reassure people and blunt the real meaning of what is being
proposed.
For example, instead of saying directly that many Medicare
services should be de-listed, the report calls on the government to
"re-define comprehensiveness." And instead of saying that patients
should be made to pay out of their own pockets for health services, the report
says that the government should "pursue alternative streams of
revenue."
However, once you strip away all the vague language, it’s
clear that the Mazankowski report is not just another bland analysis of the
problems facing the health care system.
Instead, it is a radical document that presents a
relentlessly market-driven blueprint for reform.
And it is a document which, if implemented, poses an enormous
threat to the future of Medicare – not just in Alberta, but all across the
entire country.
|